So I emailed Jenna, the donor coordinator, and let her know our top choice. I don't want to give a lot of details about her, but she's beautiful, smart, and just gives me chills when I read her profile. She seems real, not over the top, AND she notes that she would be willing (in fact would love) to have future contact with the parents. I just really like the idea of being able to stay in touch with the donor, just in case we have any genetic questions down the line.
So now, I'm just waiting to hear back from Jenna.